Archive report confirmations
Dear All,
Here are confirmations for archive reports, and one correction.
Soho# Date/Time of Post Discoverer Tel Group Images of... ===================================================================== ... 4439 May21,22 22:04:30 H.Tan,Z.Xu,Z.Yang C2 Kreutz May22,22 ... 4443 May02,22 11:13:17 P.Berrett C2 Meyer Jul12,11 4444 Jun11,22 04:51:11 H.Tan C2 Meyer Aug09,11 4445 Mar05,22 00:23:36 P.Berrett C2 NonGrp Oct16,13 4446 May01,22 09:27:53 P.Berrett C2 Meyer May12,14 4447 Mar03,22 00:55:33 P.Berrett C2 Kreutz Nov13,14 4448 May17,22 00:22:39 H.Tan C2 Marsden Dec05,15 4449 Apr15,22 03:15:25 P.Berrett C2 NonGrp Feb15,16 4450 Apr15,22 10:25:15 P.Berrett C2 NonGrp Jul24,16 4451 Mar04,22 03:55:52 P.Berrett C2 Kreutz Nov24,17 4452 Jun11,22 05:04:17 H.Tan C2 Kreutz Apr22,18 4453 Apr28,22 08:56:38 P.Berrett C2 NonGrp Jan05,19 4454 May08,22 05:26:18 P.Berrett C2 Meyer Jan20,19 4455 Jun11,22 05:07:54 H.Tan C2 Meyer Apr29-30,19 4456 Apr29,22 08:05:35 P.Berrett C2 Meyer Aug05,19 4457 Jun11,22 05:10:50 H.Tan C2 Meyer Apr11,20 4458 May26,22 19:52:22 H.Tan C2 NonGrp Aug16-17,20 4459 Jun11,22 04:57:29 H.Tan C2 Kracht Sep05,20 4460 Jun11,22 05:00:39 H.Tan C2 Kracht Sep08,20 4461* Aug01,21 03:36am T.Prestgard C2 Kreutz Nov24,20 4462# Jun21,22 11:29PM Q.Zhang C2 NonGrp Jan17,21 4463 Sep15,21 16:48:04 M.Uchina C2 Kreutz Sep15,21 4464 May08,22 16:31:39 H.Tan C2 Kracht Jan02,22 4465 Jun25,22 16:17:02 H.Tan C2 Meyer Jan24,10 4466 Jun25,22 16:01:47 H.Tan C2 Marsden Jun13,11 4467 Jun25,22 16:20:02 H.Tan C2 Kreutz Apr17,13 4468 Jun25,22 16:28:01 H.Tan C2 Meyer Jun20,13 4469 Jun25,22 16:23:01 H.Tan C2 NonGrp Aug12,13 4470 Jun25,22 16:25:02 H.Tan C2 Kreutz Dec01,13 4471 Jun25,22 16:06:53 H.Tan C2 Marsden Feb20,18 4472 Jun25,22 16:10:04 H.Tan C2 Marsden Jun27,18 4473 Jun25,22 16:13:01 H.Tan C2 Meyer Nov06,18 4474 Jun25,22 16:15:03 H.Tan C2 NonGrp Nov07,18 -- * = SohoHunter 4892 # = Email
So originally I had confirmed all the archive comets (through SOHO-4464) and was about to start June confirmations. But then I saw Hanjie posted a set of archive claims so I decided to include those as well. Normally I try and keep archive reports in order of 'image date', but I made an exception here.
Note that I verified that SOHO-4447 was NOT the same as SOHO-2827. I also verified that SOHO-4457 was not the same as SOHO-4043 (which was just a couple of hours ahead of this one).
I could not confirm Hanjie's report from report_ht_20220527002054 - the positions did not align well at all, and I tried several times to get better observations.
SOHO-4462 is interesting. Qicheng Zhang (astronomy PhD student) emailed me to point out a very faint fragment leading 323P/SOHO in data from January last year. It's very small and faint but definitely real. Comet 323P/SOHO has been in the news recently thanks to a newly published study from Man-To Hui that used a number of ground based observations of the comet to show that it is very much in the process of being destroyed by its repeated exposure to the near-Sun environment. So the discovery of this fragment is certainly not a surprise, and fits nicely into the narrative of repeated fragmentation/disruption. Congrats on your first discovery, Qicheng!
Via Rainer Kracht, SOHO-4464 is almost certainly a return of C/2004 B3 = 2009 V10 = SOHO-3081, although the timing for C/2004 B3 seems a little off (but only by about two weeks). Sometimes I do not assign SOHO numbers to 'known' returns of SOHO comets, but I typically prefer to wait for them to receive P/xxxx designations first. So I have numbered this one.
I have designated SOHO4471 as a Marsden-group comet, although Hanjie labeled it as non-group. To me, it follows the February Marsden track quite well, although did look somewhat diffuse, which is very unusual for those objects. So we will see what the orbit ends up looking like when it gets calculated. (Speaking of which, I hope to have good news about that in the coming weeks...)
That leaves us up-to-date on archive reports, and I will probably wait until next week to post the June confirmations. As always, email me with questions, comments, etc.
Karl